FLASH
Shkruar nga Pamfleti
In the GJKKO, the evaluation expert admitted that the commission relied on a 1997 document, while SPAK claims that the state suffered damage of over 4.5 million euros.
The difference between the value at which the buildings of the former Partizani Complex were privatized and what results from the SPAK expertise was at the center of the next session at the Special Court.
According to the Special Prosecution, Jamarbër Malltezi and the other persons who were recognized as owners of the land of the former Partizani Complex purchased the existing buildings for around 500 thousand euros, while the expertise conducted during the investigations values them at around 5 million euros, a difference that, according to the indictment, constitutes the basis of the economic damage caused to the state.
Elvira Lame, one of the experts who participated in the building valuation commission in 2008, testified at the hearing. During questions from prosecutor Enkeleda Millonai, she admitted that the commission referred to a 1997 document for the initial value of the buildings.
The prosecutor asked him if he was aware that there was also an accounting act from 2000 and whether investments made after 1997 had been taken into account.
" They made this one from 1997 available to us ," Lame replied, adding that communication was made with the Services Branch.
Asked whether investments made over the years were included, the expert stated that the commission had only evaluated state facilities.
" The Football Club was requested to evaluate only the state-owned facility and not the additions by third parties that were made without permission. We have determined the value only for the state property ," she said.
Millonai also asked if the valuation was made according to market prices.
" We couldn't do the evaluation as if we had apartments. You can't compare an apartment to the objects being evaluated ," the expert replied.
According to the SPAK file, the evaluation commission in the privatization procedure of the Partizani Multi-Sports Club determined that the value of the buildings was around 450 thousand euros at the current exchange rate. However, the expertise ordered during the investigations by the Special Prosecutor's Office concluded that their real value was around 4 million euros.
Even for the Partizani Football Club, the difference is considerable. The report compiled by experts Elvira Lame and Sali Preçi valued the complex at around 100 thousand euros, while SPAK experts valued it at around 1 million euros, about ten times more.
For the prosecution, these differences have caused economic damage of over 436 million lek, or about 4.5 million euros, to the detriment of the state.
SPAK solli në vëmendje edhe marrëdhënien mes ekspertes Elvira Lame dhe Jamarbër Malltezit. Sipas dosjes hetimore, Lame rezulton njohje e Malltezit dhe më pas ka bashkëpunuar me kompaninë e tij "Homeplan".
Në dosje përmendet edhe një dokument i datës 3 dhjetor 2011, sipas të cilit Elvira Lame ka përgatitur një certifikatë vlerësimi për llogari të Malltezit për një truall prej 3 mijë metrash katrorë në fshatin Priskë, për një pagesë prej rreth 1,200 eurosh.
E pyetur nga SPAK për marrëdhënien me Malltezin, Lame deklaroi se e njihte prej vitesh, por se në kohën kur kreu vlerësimin e pronave nuk ishte në dijeni se ai përfitonte nga procesi.
Procesi gjyqësor për dosjen "Partizani" do të vijojë me dëshminë e dy personave që konsiderohen kyç nga organi i akuzës, ish-Presidentit Bamir Topi dhe ish-ministrit të Mbrojtjes, Fatmir Mediu, të cilët pritet të pyeten mbi procedurat që çuan në privatizimin e ish-Kompleksit Partizani.
Pjesë nga dëshmia
Prokurorja Enkeleda Millonai: Rezulton se keni qenë anëtare në komisionin e vlerësimit në dy procedura të privatizimit të Kompleksit Partizani dhe Klubit Shumësportësh Partizani?
Elvira Lame: Mënyra si jam zgjedhur dhe kush më ka propozuar nuk e di. Më ka ardhur njoftimi me postë.
Enkeleda Millonai: Eksperti tjetër cili ka qenë?
Elvira Lame: Unë dhe Sali Preçi, i ndjerë.
Enkeleda Millonai: Sipërfaqja e domosdoshme përcaktohet përmes genplanit. Keni marrë ndonjë genplan nga Ministria e Mbrojtjes?
Elvira Lame: Për secilën nga procedurat më janë vënë në dispozicion pasi jam përzgjedhur. Dokumentet na viheshin në dispozicion nga dega, emrin e së cilës nuk e mbaj mend.
Enkeleda Millonai: Referuar VKM-së së vitit 2007, me të cilën ishit ngarkuar për vlerësimin që do të kryenit, përcaktohej se vlerësimi bëhej me genplanin. Keni marrë ndonjë genplan?
Elvira Lame: Mbaj mend se më janë vënë në dispozicion genplanet pasi u caktova. Nuk më kujtohet kush i vendosi në dispozicion. Ne kishim komunikim me një degë që ndoshta quhej Dega e Privatizimit. Ka qenë dega e Tiranës. Kryetari apo specialistët na njoftonin se erdhi genplani apo akte të tjera.
Enkeleda Millonai: Nga Instituti Gjeografik i Ushtrisë keni marrë ndonjë hartë për Sport Klub Partizanin?
Elvira Lame: Hartën na e ka vënë në dispozicion kjo degë.
Enkeleda Millonai: VKM-të që kaluan pronën në Ministrinë e Mbrojtjes apo të Kulturës, i keni parë ndonjëherë?
Elvira Lame: Kur na janë vënë në dispozicion genplanet, i kemi parë në raport me vlerësimin. Nëse do ta shikoja edhe një herë raportin, do t'i shpjegoja.
Enkeleda Millonai: Sipërfaqja është përcaktuar 29 mijë m². Ju e keni nxjerrë rreth 26 mijë m². Mund ta shpjegoni diferencën?
Elvira Lame: Regarding the surface area of the land, it is written that there was confirmation from the Municipality of Tirana, that the surface area according to this document was 26,524 m².
Enkeleda Millonai: Is it stipulated in the VKM that the area is determined by the commission?
Elvira Lame: The master plan was brought to us. We did not define it ourselves. We did the update on the ground. The differentiations between them were also made. In this specific case, the KML also prepared the master plan.
If the surface area were to change, the Municipality would make its own corrections. It's not like it's approved as it's sent, if there were to be a change in the surface area. If there were to be a change in the surface area, it would be approved by the Municipality.
Enkeleda Millonai: For the Partizani Multi-Sports Club, the area of the club that extends along Durrës Street. Do you remember the total area? You prepared it according to the 2003 Council of Ministers' Decision, where the area was also determined?
Elvira Lame: We prepared it from the acts that were made available to us.
Enkeleda Millonai: Regarding the Partizani Multi-Sports Club?
Elvira Lame: We have had confirmation from the Municipality of Tirana for both areas.
Enkeleda Millonai: Referring to the two evaluation reports, did the properties that were returned to the owners occupy the entire territory, or was there also state land and other owners?
Elvira Lame: I remember that the information was received from ASHK and ATP about the ownership. For Sport Klub Partizan we said that 866 m² was registered state property.
There was also state-owned land for the Multi-Sports Club.
Enkeleda Millonai: You referred to the initial value as of the beginning of 1997. Who gave you the reference for 1997? Meanwhile, there was an accounting act for 2000. Did you know?
Elvira Lame: This one from 1997 was made available to us.
Enkeleda Millonai: Which ones?
Elvira Lame: We had communications with the Services Branch.
Enkeleda Millonai: There have been investments from 1997 onwards and have you considered them?
Elvira Lame: The Football Club was requested to evaluate only the state-owned facility and not the additions by third parties that were made without permission.
We have determined the value only for state property. There have been investments from third parties.
Enkeleda Millonai: Was the valuation based on market value?
Elvira Lame: I went to the Real Estate Registration Office, near the Albanian Property Registry. There were no similar properties. You can't compare an apartment to the properties that were being assessed.
Sali Preçi, është djalë teze i Sali Berishes
Germojini mire se keta kane lidhje edhe me ndertimet ne Golem. Blerjet e apartamenteve ne Golem kryheshin dikur te 'Pallati Sportit Partizani'. I kane rrenjet shume me thelle se sa mendohet.
e ka kapur okazion.